Can You Use Any Body Shop With American Family Auto Insurance in the SF Bay Area?
By EV Central • SEPTEMBER 5, 2026
If you’ve been in a collision and you have American Family (AmFam) auto insurance, you might be wondering — do you have to take your car to a shop they recommend? The short answer: no, you don’t. California law gives you the right to choose any licensed repair shop, and EV Central is here to walk you through how it works.
What American Family Auto Insurance Covers
American Family offers standard collision and comprehensive coverage, plus options for rental reimbursement and OEM parts in some policies. What’s covered depends on your specific plan, but collision damage after an accident is the core of what most drivers use. AmFam is available throughout California and is a popular choice for Bay Area drivers who want solid coverage with flexible options.
California Law: You Choose Your Shop
Under California Insurance Code Section 758.5, your insurer — including American Family — cannot force you to use a specific shop. They may suggest a shop from their Direct Repair Program (DRP), but that’s their preference, not a requirement. You have the legal right to take your vehicle anywhere you choose.
The shop you pick just needs to be licensed by the Bureau of Automotive Repair (BAR). EV Central is fully licensed and I-CAR certified, with a lifetime warranty on all bodywork and paint. We handle all makes and models — gas, hybrid, and electric.
How to File an American Family Collision Claim
Filing with AmFam is straightforward. Here’s how to do it:
- Report the accident — Call AmFam at 1-800-692-6326 or file online at amfam.com or through the MyAmFam app
- Document everything — Take photos of all damage, get a police report if available, and exchange info with the other driver
- Request your preferred shop — Tell AmFam you’d like to use EV Central at 718 Bryant St, San Francisco
- Get your estimate — We’ll work directly with the adjuster and handle the paperwork on your behalf
- Approve the repair plan — Once the estimate is approved, we get your car back to pre-accident condition fast
We work with American Family and all major carriers every day. You won’t need to chase anyone down — we handle the communication for you.
SF Bay Area Cities We Serve
EV Central serves drivers across the entire Bay Area, including San Francisco, Oakland, Berkeley, San Jose, Fremont, Palo Alto, Daly City, South San Francisco, the East Bay, the Peninsula, South Bay, and Marin County. No matter where you are in the Bay, we’re your shop.
Work With a Shop That Works for You
American Family is a solid insurer — but the shop you go to is your call. At EV Central, we have the experience and certifications to restore any vehicle to pre-accident condition. Our team at 718 Bryant St in San Francisco is ready to help you navigate the claims process and get back on the road.
Call us at (415) 881-1845 or stop by 718 Bryant St, San Francisco. We’ll take it from there.